Photo: Retna

After 94 TV episodes, two movies, and three books, we’re still not sick of Sex and the City. We could never get enough of Carrie, Charlotte, Samantha, and Miranda, but it’s hard to imagine them being played by anyone other than Sarah Jessica Parker, Kristin Davis, Kim Cattrall, and Cynthia Nixon respectively—the actresses who have brought the girls to life for all that time. So, when rumors began to swirl of an SATC prequel based on Candace Bushnell’s books The Carrie Diaries and Summer in the City, we were psyched of course, but nervous, too. What actresses could possibly play the younger versions of the characters we’ve come to know and love without ruining them? Would they have the same on-screen chemistry as our girls? SJP had some hesitations, too: she told The Los Angeles Times, “I don’t think we can pretend to go back… It’s creating two histories. It’s like, ‘Oh I didn’t know that about Carrie Bradshaw.’” Kristin Davis agreed earlier this year when she told E!, “‘And then have like different people with our names? It’s kind of freaky.” Well, according to the Daily Mail, the preferences for the younger versions of the NYC BFFs have been chosen. Check them out below, and tell us: do you agree with the picks? Will these other actresses be able to pull off the roles or is the flick doomed from the get-go?

Carrie Bradshaw

Photos: Retna

Elizabeth Olsen, the Olsen twins younger sis, will be filling Sarah Jessica Parker’s Manolo Blahniks as a 1980s Carrie.

Charlotte York

Photos: Retna

Selena Gomez has got the same dark locks as Kristin Davis, but will she be able to play the sweet, wholesome Charlotte in the same way?

Samantha Jones

Photos: Retna

Blake Lively is rumored to be taking over for Kim Cattrall as the salacious Samantha Jones.

Miranda Hobbes

Photos: Retna

Emma Roberts will be playing the sarcastic red-haired lawyer-in-the-making Miranda Hobbes, a role formerly held by Cynthia Nixon.